Uptick Insight Series | The Case for Interoperable Loyalty Rewards
Published on Dec 12, 2025
Nowadays, the loyalty landscape is weighted entirely in favor with the
platform itself, rather than the customer. This is just the simple
reality that has unfolded.
Starbucks customers earn stars they can only spend at Starbucks.
Airline passengers accumulate miles locked into a single carrier’s
ecosystem.
Hotel guests collect points trapped in one chain’s rewards program.
Retailers issue gift cards that expire or disappear when businesses
close.
What do all of these have in common?
An orchestrated and fragmented loyalty landscape where customers hold
billions in unredeemable value spread across dozens of incompatible
programs they’ll most likely never fully use.
These walled gardens represent the fundamental architecture of Web2
loyalty programs, where platforms design rewards as lock-in mechanisms
rather than genuine value exchange, trapping customers in ecosystems
that benefit brands through reduced churn and making rewards
intentionally difficult to use across different merchants, eliminating
any real flexibility or liquidity that would give consumers actual
control over the value they’ve earned through years of purchases and
engagement.
Data shows us that the average American household participates in 18
loyalty programs but actively uses only half of them, leaving an
estimated $100 billion in unredeemed rewards sitting idle across
credit card points, retail programs, and membership tiers, as
expiration dates, minimum redemption thresholds, blackout periods, and
ecosystem restrictions transform what brands market as customer
benefits into sophisticated instruments for capturing value that
consumers helped create but can never fully extract or transfer.
We can draw clear parallels to platform economies more broadly, where
value concentrates around infrastructure owners who extract maximum
revenue through artificial constraints. Just as social media platforms
lock in user data and subscription services make cancellation
deliberately complex, other industries rely on similar tactics to
prevent users from moving assets freely. Whether that’s airlines
blocking point transfers, retailers voiding gift cards when stores
close, or brands imposing expiration dates, they all serve the same
function, which is enforcing technical limitations to capture value.
Companies need customer retention to survive competitive markets,
making loyalty programs feel essential for building long-term
relationships, but every restriction imposed on rewards points that
can’t be gifted to friends, transferred to other programs, or redeemed
for anything beyond a narrow set of approved purchases represents a
very deliberate choice to prioritize platform control over customer
freedom, extracting value from relationships built on the premise of
mutual benefit when the architecture actually concentrates all
flexibility and decision-making power with brands.
The alternative is if loyalty programs instead ran on programmable
infrastructure with cross-chain compatibility, and brands could issue
rewards as interoperable assets that customers genuinely own and can
use across multiple merchants or even trade on open markets, creating
ecosystems where value flows based on utility as opposed to artificial
restrictions. It would transform loyalty from a lock-in mechanism into
a genuine expression of customer preference backed by flexible, liquid
assets that appreciate based on market demand.
Uptick infrastructure addresses these challenges through protocols
that treat loyalty rewards as programmable property with cross-chain
capabilities, so customers never have to give up control to
single-platform ecosystems when their rewards enter broader Web3
markets. This is made possible with smart contracts that are able to
execute automatic transfers whenever customers want to use rewards
across different merchants, turning what is now trapped value into
genuinely portable assets. Programmable NFTs representing loyalty
tiers or accumulated benefits are able to move smoothly between
compatible platforms, allowing customers to keep their status and
privileges across multiple brands that recognize the same
decentralized credentials.
It may sound like an ideological Web3 fever dream, but actually, it
doesn’t have to, because we now have the infrastructure available to
enable these unique and innovative scenarios at scale.
In this article, we’re going to explore six practical scenarios where
programmable loyalty infrastructure creates true ownership for
customers, from coffee shops issuing tradeable reward tokens to
airlines allowing cross-carrier point pooling, showing us how brands
can build customer relationships without resorting to the
walled-garden restrictions that currently dominate digital loyalty
programs and leave billions in consumer value permanently stranded in
unusable formats.
Let’s get into it.
Regional coffee shops competing against Starbucks face a massive
challenge, as customers hesitate to split their purchases between
multiple brands knowing their loyalty progress resets to zero every
time they visit a different café, creating powerful network effects
where the largest chain with the most locations captures
disproportionate value simply because their rewards program covers
more geographic territory regardless of coffee quality or customer
service.
A customer living between two neighborhoods might prefer the
independent roaster near their office and the cozy local café near
their home, but Starbucks’ ubiquitous rewards program that works
nationwide makes abandoning either independent shop rational because
splitting purchases means neither smaller chain’s loyalty program ever
reaches redemption thresholds, as 25 visits to one café and 25 to
another generates zero rewards, whereas 50 visits to Starbucks unlocks
free drinks and status tiers.
Uptick’s Loyalty and Rights Management module addresses this through
programmable NFTs that independent coffee shops can issue as unified
rewards.
Three regional chains in the same city could collectively operate a
shared loyalty program through smart contracts that recognize
purchases at any participating location. Customers accumulating points
at the independent roaster, the neighborhood café, and the downtown
shop would see their rewards combine into a single balance tracked
on-chain through Uptick’s Programmable NFT Protocol, creating the
geographic coverage that previously only national chains could offer
without requiring independent businesses to give up their brand
identity or customer relationships to a centralized intermediary.
When customers reach reward thresholds, smart contracts could be
designed to automatically issue NFTs representing free drinks or
discounts redeemable at any participating café, and these rewards are
stored in decentralized wallets controlled by customers through
private keys rather than accounts managed by individual brands that
basically disappear when businesses close or change ownership.
Uptick Cross-chain Bridge and IBC protocols enable the potential for
these rewards to be earned on one blockchain ecosystem and work across
others, meaning a café operating on Ethereum-based point-of-sale
systems could, in theory, accept loyalty NFTs issued by a roaster
using Polygon infrastructure, removing technical barriers that
currently create a disconnect for merchant adoption of loyalty
technology.
We also eliminate the platform extraction that occurs when third-party
loyalty aggregators charge cafés 15–20% transaction fees to
participate in multi-brand programs, because smart contracts are able
to execute reward issuance and redemption automatically with minimal
gas fees paid to validators rather than rent extracted by
intermediaries controlling proprietary software.
This creates aligned incentives where cafés sharing a loyalty
ecosystem actually benefit from collective customer retention and
independent shops can compete on coffee quality and service rather
than loyalty program scale, knowing customers no longer face penalties
for splitting purchases between multiple preferred brands.
Airline loyalty programs trap passengers in single-carrier ecosystems
where accumulated miles become worthless when preferred routes get
discontinued or when competing airlines offer better schedules, as
transfer restrictions, blackout dates, and dynamic pricing algorithms
designed to maximize revenue extraction mean travelers holding 50,000
miles often find redemption options limited to inconvenient flights
during off-peak times or undesirable routes that generate minimal
value relative to the spending required to earn those miles in the
first place.
A business traveler based in a mid-sized city might accumulate Delta
miles for East Coast routes, United miles for West Coast travel, and
American miles for international connections as different carriers
serve different destinations from their home airport, but because
these point balances are disconnected from one another, it means mean
none reach the thresholds required for premium cabin upgrades or
desirable reward flights, and transfer restrictions prevent
consolidating miles into a single program that would actually provide
enough balance for meaningful redemptions.
Uptick’s Programmable NFT Protocol could allow airlines to tokenize
miles as programmable NFTs that travelers genuinely own and can pool
across carriers through decentralized wallets they control.
This scenario could enable an alliance of regional airlines
collectively issuing a unified points currency tracked on-chain and
redeemable for flights on any participating carrier. Smart contracts
built on Uptick’s infrastructure could be used to handle conversion
rates automatically when travelers book flights, where 10,000 points
earned on Carrier A could translate into equivalent value on Carrier B
based on predetermined exchange rates embedded in the NFT metadata or
smart contract logic, creating liquidity where travelers can finally
consolidate these disconnected balances into usable redemption values.
Well, what about the payment side of things I hear you ask?
Uptick’s Omnichannel Payment Module addresses settlement complexity by
handling multi-currency transactions automatically when travelers
redeem cross-carrier points, as smart contracts calculate the value
owed to each airline based on the flight selected and execute payments
from the traveler’s tokenized point balance to the operating carrier’s
treasury wallet without requiring manual reconciliation or centralized
clearinghouses that extract fees for processing inter-airline
settlements.
Uptick’s Decentralized Data Service (UDS) could also track point earn
rates, redemption histories, and program rule changes immutably
on-chain, creating transparent audit trails where airlines operating
under DAO governance models would require community consensus recorded
through on-chain votes before devaluing miles or altering terms.
If airlines operated loyalty programs through Uptick’s infrastructure,
travelers could even trade loyalty rewards on secondary markets if
they prefer cash liquidity over flight redemptions, because
programmable NFTs representing reward balances or specific redemption
rights become tradeable assets where other travelers seeking specific
routes could purchase these NFTs directly from holders rather than
earning through flights.
This creates price discovery based on actual redemption value rather
than incredibly opaque internal valuations controlled by airline
revenue management systems that inflate point requirements without
corresponding increases in customer benefits.
Gift card purchases in the United States exceed $160 billion annually,
but an estimated $3 billion goes unredeemed each year as cards expire,
businesses close, or recipients simply never use credit locked into
brands they don’t frequent, creating a wealth transfer from consumers
to retailers who receive upfront cash for products never delivered and
book unredeemed balances as breakage revenue on financial statements
that treat customer losses as corporate gains.
If you’re a recipient receiving five $25 gift cards from different
retailers, then you face forced spending at specific stores regardless
of whether those brands offer products they actually want, as gift
card credit locked into a sporting goods chain for example, provides
zero value to someone who doesn’t play sports, and fashion retailer
credit becomes worthless when the recipient’s style preferences don’t
align with that brand’s aesthetic, leading to reluctant purchases of
items they wouldn’t normally buy simply to avoid letting value expire
unused.
Uptick’s Loyalty and Rights Management module transforms gift cards
into programmable assets issued as NFTs that retail coalitions could
accept interchangeably across participating merchants.
Sporting goods stores, fashion retailers, home goods shops, and
restaurants could collectively operate a unified gift card system
through smart contracts that recognize value regardless of which
specific merchant originally sold the card. Recipients holding $100 in
tokenized retail credit stored in their digital wallet could spend
that balance at any participating store based on their actual
preferences, as smart contracts handle settlement automatically
between the merchant providing goods and the original card issuer
holding the customer’s prepaid funds.
If retail coalitions operated through Uptick’s infrastructure, gift
card NFTs could include programmable rules embedded in metadata that
maintain brand restrictions if desired, as a coffee chain wanting to
preserve brand-specific gifts could issue NFTs redeemable only at
their locations, but these same NFTs stay tradeable on secondary
markets where recipients preferring different brands can sell their
coffee credit to genuine coffee enthusiasts and use the proceeds to
purchase gift card NFTs for retailers they actually use.
This would create liquidity where recipients extract full value from
gifts even when the specific brand doesn’t match their preferences.
Uptick Cross-chain Bridge and IBC protocols could enable gift card
NFTs to work across different Web3 ecosystems that retailers might
choose based on their existing payment infrastructure, as a merchant
operating point-of-sale systems on Ethereum can accept gift cards
issued by a coalition partner using Binance Smart Chain infrastructure
because Uptick’s cross-chain compatibility maintains NFT functionality
and value verification regardless of the underlying blockchain.
This removes the technical barriers that currently prevent smaller
retailers from participating in coalition loyalty programs dominated
by large corporations with resources to build proprietary cross-brand
redemption systems.
Uptick’s programmable infrastructure also eliminates the artificial
scarcity and expiration dates that retailers impose on gift cards to
drive breakage revenue, as smart contracts can specify that tokenized
credit never expires unless the coalition collectively votes to modify
terms through on-chain governance recorded in Social DAO frameworks,
creating transparency where customers know that value they’ve paid for
or received as gifts won’t vanish through arbitrary expiration
policies designed to transfer wealth from consumers to merchants
without delivering corresponding products or services.
Travel and lifestyle brands increasingly advertise their environmental
commitments, but their loyalty programs still mostly reward raw spend
instead of lower-carbon choices, so a customer taking three short-haul
flights in economy earns fewer miles than a frequent business traveler
in premium cabins, even if the former actively chooses trains, direct
routes, or eco-certified hotels whenever possible.
Uptick’s GreenTech Service and Programmable NFT Protocol enables the
possibility for airlines, rail networks, hotel groups, and mobility
providers to issue interoperable ‘green miles’ for verifiable
low-carbon behaviors.
This could be anything from choosing rail instead of air on specific
corridors, booking eco-certified accommodation, or offsetting
emissions through audited carbon projects recorded on-chain.
These green miles function as programmable NFTs that can be redeemed
across a coalition of participating brands, traded on secondary
markets, or upgraded into higher-tier sustainability badges tied to
Uptick DID, where smart contracts verify eligibility using oracle-fed
emissions data and automatically distribute rewards through the
Loyalty and Rights Management module.
When mobility providers and hospitality groups use Uptick’s
cross-chain infrastructure, a traveler who earns green rewards on a
European rail network could redeem them with a regional hotel partner
or electric car-sharing service operating on a different blockchain,
as the Uptick Cross-chain Bridge and IBC protocols maintain metadata,
provenance, and reward logic across chains.
This architecture turns scattered sustainability campaigns into a
unified, interoperable green loyalty layer that finally aligns
incentives for travelers, brands, and most importantly, the planet.
Gym memberships, coworking spaces, entertainment venues, and
professional clubs operate isolated access systems where monthly fees
grant entry to single locations or limited networks, forcing customers
to choose between convenient neighborhood gyms with basic equipment or
premium downtown facilities with comprehensive amenities, as
multi-location access requires expensive top-tier memberships that
most customers can’t justify despite valuing flexibility to use
different facilities based on their schedule or location on any given
day.
A professional working remotely three days per week might value a
coworking membership near their home, but traditional providers charge
full monthly rates for single-location access even though this
customer only needs the space occasionally and would generate more
value from a flexible pass working across multiple coworking networks
where they could book desks in different neighborhoods based on their
daily plans, and subscription structures designed around monthly
recurring revenue make per-day access uneconomical despite better
matching actual usage patterns.
Uptick’s Programmable NFT Protocol enables membership organizations to
issue access credentials as NFTs that customers genuinely own and can
use across participating venues.
With smart contracts, we can verify entitlements and execute automatic
revenue sharing between the venue providing services and the original
membership issuer, where a coalition of coworking spaces collectively
recognizes member NFTs and allows booking across any participating
location with smart contracts handling settlement automatically based
on actual usage tracked on-chain through Uptick’s Decentralized Data
Service (UDS).
When customers purchase memberships tokenized as NFTs, they receive
programmable assets with metadata specifying access levels, usage
allowances, and privilege tiers that venues can verify through Uptick
DID without requiring centralized databases that store customer
information or payment credentials that create security
vulnerabilities, as members prove their access rights through
cryptographic signatures without revealing personal data beyond the
specific entitlements needed to authorize entry.
This creates privacy-preserving verification and eliminates the
surveillance infrastructure currently embedded in membership systems
that track customer movements and activities across venues.
The Uptick Cross-chain Bridge and IBC protocols allow membership NFTs
to maintain functionality when venues operate on different blockchain
infrastructures, as a gym chain using Cosmos-based access systems can
verify credentials issued by a coworking network on Ethereum because
Uptick’s interoperability maintains NFT metadata and smart contract
logic across chains, removing technical barriers that currently
prevent smaller membership organizations from participating in
coalition access programs that require expensive API integrations and
proprietary software development to achieve cross-venue compatibility.
Uptick’s infrastructure could also support secondary markets where
members can sell or rent their access credentials when they’re not
using them, as someone traveling for a month could list their gym
membership NFT for rent at a discounted rate that other fitness
enthusiasts can purchase for temporary access, creating liquidity
where membership value flows to customers who genuinely use facilities
rather than being captured by venues through subscription models that
charge full price regardless of actual utilization.
Smart contracts can automatically return ownership to the original
member after rental periods expire without requiring manual transfers
or trust in temporary users to return access credentials they’ve
borrowed.
Creators today build audiences across multiple platforms, however
their ‘loyalty’ mechanics are isolated inside each walled garden, as
Twitch subs, YouTube memberships, Patreon tiers, and newsletter perks
all operate on separate rails where fans effectively re-earn status
from scratch every time they follow the same creator into a new
ecosystem.
Uptick’s Web3 Creator Economy model and Loyalty and Rights Management
module can enable creators to issue portable membership passes as
programmable NFTs that function as cross-platform loyalty primitives.
This means that a fan who holds a ‘Tier 3’ creator pass in their
wallet could unlock perks across any compatible app that integrates
Uptick’s Web3 API, and smart contracts can encode benefits like gated
content, early access, discounts on merch, or governance rights in a
Social DAO, with Uptick DID providing verifiable, privacy-preserving
identity so fans can prove membership without exposing personal
information to each new platform.
Because these passes live on Uptick infrastructure and have EVM and
WASM support, they can be recognized in video platforms, audio apps,
metaverse spaces, and e-commerce stores simultaneously, with the
Uptick Decentralized Data Service (UDS) aggregating anonymized
engagement data so creators understand how and where loyal fans show
up without relying on any single platform’s closed analytics.
This transforms loyalty from platform-owned follower counts into
creator- and community-owned membership assets that move freely across
the evolving stack of Web3 and Web2 experiences fans choose to use.
Loyalty programs designed as interoperable assets create fundamentally
different customer relationships compared to walled gardens that trap
value in single-brand ecosystems, where restrictions serve platform
interests through lock-in and artificial scarcity instead of genuine
mutual benefit, as customers willing to concentrate purchases with
preferred brands based on product quality and service excellence don’t
require coercive architecture that makes switching competitors
punitive through forfeited rewards and reset progress.
The transition from proprietary points to programmable assets doesn’t
eliminate brand loyalty but instead reveals which customer
relationships genuinely reflect preference versus those sustained
primarily through switching costs and sunk cost fallacies, where
travelers continue using airlines they dislike because abandoning
accumulated miles feels wasteful and retail customers make suboptimal
purchases to avoid letting expiring points go unredeemed, creating
engagement metrics that brands mistake for satisfaction when the
underlying dynamic actually represents customer frustration with
trapped value they can’t extract or transfer. Press enter or click to
view image in full size
Uptick’s infrastructure shows us that loyalty programs can align
customer and brand interests through transparent value exchange built
on portable assets, where coffee shops compete on quality knowing
customers face no penalties for trying competitors, airlines earn
traveler preference by offering superior routes and service rather
than extracting value through opaque point devaluations, retailers
build genuine relationships with shoppers who choose their stores
based on products rather than gift card credit they’re reluctant to
waste, and membership organizations attract customers by providing
excellent facilities instead of relying on subscription inertia to
sustain revenue from members who no longer actively use services they
continue paying for month after month.
These scenarios demonstrate practical applications of programmable
infrastructure, where loyalty transitions from extraction to genuine
value creation, and rewards evolve from platform lock-in mechanisms
into customer-owned assets that appreciate based on utility, keeping
their value regardless of which brands customers choose to patronize.
Flexibility and liquidity serve both customers and brands by revealing
true preferences and eliminating adversarial dynamics in walled garden
systems.
Essentially, programmable infrastructure frees customers from
forfeiting years of accumulated rewards when switching providers,
brands compete on genuine merit through product quality and service
excellence, and this results in customers retaining full control over
earned value. This reimagines customer relationships in markets that
respect ownership, enable choice, and reward authentic preference over
artificial lock-in.
The exciting part is that the infrastructure exists today to make this
vision a reality.